And when I say "everyone", I mean why do people with respectable taste like Girl Talk? Particularly, when his music is far from having even an understandable appeal for music enthusiasts. I'm just going to rattle off a list of reasons why his appeal is so confusing to me:
1) He does the same thing on every single album. There's no progression. Play a song from Night Ripper next to a song from All Day and I couldn't tell you which came from what album. How uninteresting is that?
2) His selection of samples is uninteresting and, at best, only palatable as novelty. Once novelty wears off, then what? Is anyone genuinely excited about hearing Tiny Dancer mashed up with Juicy? I know both those songs. They're ubiquitous within the 18-30 year old demographic of music listeners thanks to Ben Folds, Almost Famous, and... well, whoever executed Biggie (the C.I.A.). Hearing them put together evokes about a 5 second interest in my head, the equivalent of: "Oh yeah. That's kinda fun. Don't really get the point/purpose, though. If it's to be danceable, couldn't I just put one or the other on and be just as sated in my thirst for ubiquitous karaoke mainstream songs?" In the meantime, play that shit for one of my music-loving, vinyl-ordering, skinny-jeans wearing friends and watch their faces light up: "Man, what a beat! Greg Gillis is
on point, SON!" Meanwhile, I'm sitting there with a beat up Avalanches record in my hands, looking like Charlie Brown. Girl Talk's "songs" are the equivalent of YouTube viral videos of kittens that say, "Nom nom nom." Not even! At least the "nom nom nom" kittens reward repeat viewings. I listen to a Girl Talk song once and I throw it away like a half eaten Twinkie: "Oh, I get it. He put that song with that song. Cool. Next."
3) It preys on people's nostalgia and love of 60s-90s pastiche to an unforgivable level. This music isn't challenging in the least. It might as well be sold at Wal-Mart next to "Now: Vol. 46" and People Magazine. I thought the idea of sampling was that as a pastiche recycled art, it turned something old into something new. In the case of Girl Talk, it turns something old into something old played over top of or underneath something less old.
4) Those Girl Talk concerts look unbearably stupid. I bet all those people are really stupid.
See 2:55 for evidence of this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TxcCfqbazpg&feature=related